They appear to be more social during mating season with many displays of dominance occurring with mature bucks, while younger bucks conduct similar engagements as a form of social bonding. Mule deer have a white rump and a tail with a black tip at the end of it. Habitat: Blacktails are a subspecies of mule deer found in western Oregon from the Coast Range east to the Cascade Mountains. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Their favorite meals are ferns, huckleberry, blackberries, apples, cranberry, elderberry, and more. For the rifle hunters, a flat shooting caliber such as .270, .243 or .30-06 would be ideal for blacktail and achieve the desired result. Another difference is physical shape. The white-tailed deer is known for having a bushy brown tail with a white underside for which it is named, while the black-tailed deer has a shorter, less bushy, black tail. The black-tailed deer is a subspecies of the mule deer. Be educated. The body also has a different color pattern, which tends to be a lot darker and closer to a gray color in the fall to assist them with blending in their rugged environments. This color variation doesnt occur in black-tailed deer. Mule Deer vs White-tail: 5 Key Differences Explained. Their tail is much smaller and has a range of colors on it. Everything You Want To Know About Muntjac, Discover The Largest Whitetail Deer Ever Recorded, What Do White-Tailed Deer Eat? In Iowa, people chase some of the worlds largest Whitetail deer. It has a high protein content of 15-20%, depending on the cut. In most cases, the mule deer will have significantly longer ears than a whitetail. The shape and angle of their ears dont affect how well either of them can hear. As you can see, these animals eat similar types of food, but they eat many unique foods based on where they live worldwide. Although their diets are largely similar, whitetail deer typically have a wider choice of foods due to their habitat and larger stomachs. Antler formation may be the easiest way to tell a mule deer and a whitetail apart. If black-tailed deer were to migrate south, the diseases that whitetails are immune to would kill them quickly. . Coues deer are found in Arizona and are much smaller than the Northern White-tailed deer. Those big old ears are there for a reason and a muley knows how to use them. if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[250,250],'outdoorsmecca_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_10',107,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-outdoorsmecca_com-medrectangle-4-0');if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[250,250],'outdoorsmecca_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_11',107,'0','1'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-outdoorsmecca_com-medrectangle-4-0_1');.medrectangle-4-multi-107{border:none!important;display:block!important;float:none!important;line-height:0;margin-bottom:15px!important;margin-left:auto!important;margin-right:auto!important;margin-top:15px!important;max-width:100%!important;min-height:250px;min-width:250px;padding:0;text-align:center!important}. That way, we can see how theyre different in obvious ways, like body type, and less-obvious ways, like species. These deer are found throughout all of Central America and portions of northern South America. So, at least for now, whitetails and black-tails remain distinctly different species of deer. Any alfalfa farmer will tell you, alfalfa can attract deer as well as any other type of feed. Their tracks and scat are almost identical, and they interact with their surroundings nearly the same way as well, as youll see chewed shrubs and foliage. Their dull brownish color alone is enough to make spotting them difficult, but it is often their whitish rumps that are a giveaway. Whitetail and mule deer are two related deer . Find a group of does and wait for the buck, he wont be far behind. When the ice melted, blacktails spread along the west coast, while the mule deer moved into the interior of the continent. I graduated from Rowan University in 2014 with degrees in English and Education. The white-tailed deer is larger than the black-tailed deer, weighing up to 405 lbs, while the black-tailed deer weighs 225 lbs at its maximum. Of course, Bergmanns Rule makes plenty of sense when you think about colder climates versus warmer climates. Weight: Up to 94kg (females up to 56kg). 20+ Foods, The 4 Best Deer Repellents: Reviewed and Ranked, in Canada, California, Oregon, and Washington State in the continental United States. Doe front tracks on the other hand tend to be just slightly larger or nearly the same size as their hind tracks. As the name suggests, black-tailed deer have a wide, triangular tail with a dark brown or black top and a white underside. Body size is usually relative to age, genetics, health, nutrition and geographic location. Whitehead, Jr., C. J. If you have any questions for me, fill out a form on the contact page, send me an email at karson@huntinggearinsiders.com or leave a comment on the below. As you can see, many different types of deer roam across North (and South) America. 7+6+3=16. They are much smaller than Mule deer but larger than Blacktail deer, these are the most popular big game in North America. Updated weekly by fish and wildlife biologists throughout the state. Our blacktails in the Cascades have some muley influence and migrate. This is another quick way to identify one from the other. Since both deer share similar biology, their diets are similar as they both eat shrubs, grasses, tree foliage and various herbaceous plants known as forbs. Whitetail are the oldest living species of deer at 3.5 million years old. Antlers In some cases, the many barriers to crossbreeding fail and . Deer Tracks. Sharper toes typically indicate a younger deer, but this varies . Use all of these traits and never just one or two to help identify the breed of deer youre looking at before taking the shot. Mule deer has mule-like large ears but those are small in whitetail deer. Deer hunting is a great way to spend quality time with the ones you love. Interestingly, they live in rural and suburban areas, so people commonly see them. Furthermore, the ears of the whitetail deer are small while the ears of the mule deer are large like those in the mule. When it comes to identifying the differences between the two, we can start with the names of each deer. in 2011 the plaintiffs noted in oral arguments before the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals that the difference is between a claimed 21 deer per square mile carrying capacity in the project EIS, . Whitetail deer will have a different pattern all together. Deer Population by State: How Many Deer are in the U.S.? That's 30-inches difference in antler material! Mule deers form larger groups than blacktails, so fighting over social hierarchy and mating order is more common, explaining the need for stronger, bigger antlers. Thanks Orygun. According to Western states Departments of Natural resources, if a Blacktail deer moves further west, it becomes a Mule deer. The most obvious one is the fur on the rump of each deer. As an avid outdoors person (hunting and fishing mostly)I love to mention and link to various products and gear I use. They use it like a horse uses their tail and keep moving it around to ward off flies. An adult, male, black-tailed deer can reach up to 200lbs while whitetail males can reach up to 300lbs. This white portion of the tail can only be seen when the deer "flags" or . Mule deer typically have a little bigger and heavier body, even though you may have a hard time seeing this difference between whitetail and mule deer in the field. Pumps, Automatics, Over & Unders, Side by Sides, Single Shot & more. The best time for this is obviously during the November rut and the one call that works best is a bleating fawn. As an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Despite the differences in flavor between mule and whitetail listed above, don't be upset if you can't really taste the difference between the two. Size Whitetail Deer An adult, male, black-tailed deer can reach up to 200lbs while whitetail males can reach up to 300lbs. Blacktails also have wider, bushier tails compared to the mule deer whose tail is longer and thinner. This color can get even darker, almost black in some cases, in the winter months as the deer lives in more heavily forested areas, as the darker color helps conceal it in dark forests. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Big game hunting and deer hunting especially have been around for thousands of years. I'm a freelance writer with 8 years of experience. 2) are our most common deer subspecies. Email theOregon Fish & Wildlife Commission at odfw.commission@odfw.oregon.gov. In fact, several species and subspecies of deer are found throughout the world today. For example, a buck may have a net score of 155 as a typical, but a net score of 185 as a non-typical. The Mule deer are often a lot larger than their whitetail counterparts. In the spring when it starts to warm up they shed their grey color coat and grow a new brownish color coat. When glassing for mule deer, focus on areas that have thickish cover with spaced-out openings. The blacktail deer is usually darker than the mule deer, having a more consistent gray color. A whitetail gets its name from its tail. If they are much smaller, a fawn probably made them. Others have hunted and continue to hunt both. JSTOR, Available here: https://www.jstor.org/stable/3504024, National Wildlife Federation, Available here: https://www.nwf.org/Educational-Resources/Wildlife-Guide/Mammals/Mule-Deer, State of Alaska Department of Fish and Game, Available here: https://www.adfg.alaska.gov/index.cfm?adfg=muledeer.main, Mule Deer Foundation, Available here: https://muledeer.org/mule-deer-black-tailed-facts-biology/#:~:text=Mule%20deer%20are%20distributed%20throughout,the%20Canadian%20provinces%20of%20Saskatchewan%2C. Blacktail mothers are more protective and will chase away other deer to protect their young. When a Whitetail is fleeing, it will throw its tail up in the air waving goodbye to your chance! This is all about heat dissipation. They are edge-adapted species using the region's dense forest cover . The most significant differences between a mule deer and a black-tailed deer lie in their size and the morphology of their tails. The entire mating season lasts from October to December. I'm a freelance writer with 8 years of experience. Whitetails almost always have brown rumps. Stories of successfully calling in muleys or bringing in bucks by rattling antlers together are few and far between, but it may still be a good option to get a buck to show himself, if the signs of tracks are fresh and you are certain he is held up in some dense brush. Whitetails are subject to a different phenomenon than blacktails, which is Bergmann's Rule. These qualities can help immediately differentiate the two species, but other differences exist between the deer. Blacktail deer are generally much smaller than Mule deer and form their racks similarly to that of Whitetail deer. Strangely enough, these deer never mate with one another, even in areas where their populations overlap. This process usually involves removing the entrails, reproductive tract, heart, lungs, diaphragm and part of the esophagus. Contact the AZ Animals editorial team. But it by no means implies that just because you have hunted a mule deer, there is no need to pursue a blacktail. The pointed end is forward. Whitetails don't do that. Blacktails also have wider, bushier tails compared to the mule deer whose tail is longer and thinner. The white-tailed deer is Odocoileus virginianus, and the black-tailed deer is Odocoileus hemionus columbianus. I've measured P&Y Blacktails who have won the biennual bowhunting awards in California bigger than any Mule deer I've killed. The mule deer and the black-tailed deer have different ranges. Enter your email in the box below to get the most mind-blowing animal stories and videos delivered directly to your inbox every day. Predator Hunting (Coyote, Bobcat, Fox, Wolf, Cougar, etc. Antler size We are going to base antler size off the Boone and Crockett recording system for both the mule and blacktail deer. Thats because their coats change color depending on the season. Do not hesitate to call your local Game Warden or Department of Natural Resources if you have questions. In the Coastal Regions of North Carolina, the average size of a Whitetail is a mere 100 pounds or less. What to put in water when boiling deer skull. Columbian white-tailed and black-tailed deer share the same habitat in some parts of western Oregon. Mule deer are slightly more accepting to hunters and pressure. Thisvideo and related graphicillustrateseveral key characteristics to help hunters (and others) distinguish between the two. To keep things straightforward, when referring to blacktail it will be with regards to the Columbia blacktail. The predominant successful breeding among hybrids is between white-tailed bucks and mule deer does (Carr and Hughes 1993, Cathey et al. However, the black-tailed deer has a black non-bushy tail. A dominant mule deer buck may have a home range as large as 80 square miles. So for instance, a buck comes in and you can see a 7" G2, a 6" G3 and a 3" G4. They can be found in North and South America, New Zealand, Antilles, the Caribbean, and some European countries like Czech, Finland, and Romania. Yet, the mule deer has a long, thin tail that is mostly white and ends in a black tip, while the black-tailed deer has a wider tail that is black when hanging down. WATCH: Sharks biting alligators, the most epic lion battles, and MUCH more. For a very rough on the hoof estimate on an average sized deer. They tend to live near rivers and fields where water and food are easy to come by. These are two subspecies of the mule deer, sharing some but not all qualities with the main stem of the species. Generally speaking, whitetails are eating more foods that produce a more desired taste than mule deer. This is different than how Whitetail antlers grow, which come from a single beam and branch out as they grow. To the untrained eye and on the surface, all these animals are just deer so we are going to dive into the differences between these amazing creatures. This is an old video and refers to the Roseburg population of the Columbian white-tailed deer as endangered. . You should study photos, videos and live deer to increase your knowledge so that you can make that snap-decision you might have to make when in the field. The color of each deers fur is dependent on their habitat and time of the year, with slight changes happening as the seasons change. A white- tail/mule deer hybrid has metatarsal glands that split the difference in location, appearance and length (between 2 to 4 inches). We may earn a small commission on purchases made through our links. Moreover, they share the same forking antler style that differs from the white-tailed deer. As the white-tailed deers name suggests, this creature has a bushy, brown tail with a white underside. Their antlers are appealing, because of the velvety fur covering those. Do Cast Iron Wood Stoves Need Fire Bricks? The farther south you travel, whitetail females are more similar to black-tail females in size and weight. And you should never just use one or two of these visual characteristics to make the decision to shoot. An adult buck will weigh from 150 to . They try to see what is making the noise before bounding off. United States Department of Agriculture, Available here: https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/Internet/FSE_DOCUMENTS/nrcs142p2_042116.pdf, State of Alaska Department of Fish and Game, Available here: https://www.adfg.alaska.gov/index.cfm?adfg=deer.main, N.C. While the specifics of each deers size come down to genetics and diet, generally mule deer will be larger than blacktail deer. With a shoulder height of 31 42 and a nose-to-tail length of 3.9 6.9 ft. A mature mule deer buck will tip the scales from 160 to 330 lbs. White-Tailed Deer vs Black-Tailed Deer: What Are the Differences? Both mule deer and whitetail deer hear extremely well. The difference between whitetail, mule, and blacktail deer There are close relatives of the caribou, moose, and elk on the other side of the Pacific. They eat grass, nuts, forbs, mushrooms, and fruits. http://www.dfg.ca.gov/wildlife/hunting/deer/publications.html, ISO Replacement Forearm Pads for a Beretta Extrema. Some of the best examples of deer tracks are found in wet sand or shallow mud just like this one. Mule deer antlers can vary greatly but will hardly ever resemble the formation and patterns of a whitetail. Its estimated that there are 30 million deer worldwide. But as their habitats and ranges are rather separated, each has a different diet unique to their areas. Alfalfa is easily digestible but will not come cheap. They are a much better option than corn or hay. Bucks in our coast range will live most of the year (cept the rut) in less than 1/2 sq mile if they have food cover and water. Another major difference between these two creatures is their antlers. Mule deer feel safest on brush covered hillsides, deep draws and areas that offer a good mix between browsing and grazing options. So no matter what you are going after, be sure to check the local regulations and educate yourself. Did you know that due to their size, sometimes mule deer antlers can be worth more than other antlers! Whitetail deer gallop away when they are scared. Damn Dan. The antlers of Columbia . This type of deer is polyestrous and is a short day breeder. tailed and Mule deer . Sitkas also are larger in the body. The black-tailed mature bucks, specifically the Columbia blacktail deer, weigh in around 150 to 200lbs with the does coming in considerably lighter. Mule and blacktail deer have even been known to interbreed, so a deer with a hybrid of each species characteristics is possible. These are just the most prominent differences between these deer, but they are unique in other ways too! Genetic samples from far outside of the "cross-over" zone were used to establish those value ranges. The Sitka deer or Sitka black-tailed deer ( Odocoileus hemionus sitkensis) is a subspecies of mule deer ( Odocoileus hemionus ), similar to the Columbian black-tailed subspecies ( O. h. colombianus ). Yes, we get it body size within a species can vary according to diet and habitat but for the most part, the figures below are general sizes. The Columbia blacktails have bigger racks.. They prefer more open, sparsely forested areas that have rugged, rocky terrain. Mule deer are so aptly named due to their large ears that resemble that of a Mule. And it comes down to what side of the line they died upon. Given that they can inhabit the same area and can even interbreed, knowing the difference between them can be tricky. if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'outdoorsmecca_com-medrectangle-3','ezslot_16',118,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-outdoorsmecca_com-medrectangle-3-0'); Blacktail deer can be found along the west coast, from southern Alaska, to British Columbia, to northern Mexico, and even to islands off the coast of Vancouver. . Deer are native to all continents except Australia and Antarctica, and many species have been widely introduced beyond their original habitats as game . The mule deer has larger ears than the black-tailed deer, a quality that grants this deer its name. In the warmer months, blacktail moves to higher elevations into steep mountain ranges where there are fewer predators and new growth of vegetation. Some of the different Whitetail subspecies are northern white-tailed deer, Carmen Mountains white-tailed deer, Key deer or Florida Keys white-tailed deer, and Coues deer. ContactODFW's public service representative at odfw.info@odfw.oregon.gov. Most pure mule deer have forks in their antlers. Similarities of Blacktail Deer vs Mule Deer, Coues Deer vs Whitetail Deer: Differences & Comparison. I've been hunting since I was 8 and shed hunting even before that. Mule deer are the larger of the two species, having a larger frame, being heavier, and having longer antlers. These deer are found along the Pacific Coast of North America. A lot of the rest of the area has cattle on it and that just destroys any native sign. Shotguns. When whitetails and black-tails mate in captivity, their offspring wont survive in the wild. Whitetail deer have spread out more than mule deer. Make spotting them difficult, but this varies of a whitetail is fleeing, it a. And blacktail deer are large like those in the Coastal Regions of North America the U.S. identify from. Can help immediately differentiate the two, we can start with the main stem of the quot. Populations overlap interestingly, they live in rural and suburban areas, so a deer with a underside! Our links interestingly, they live in rural and suburban areas, so people commonly them. Whitetail males can reach up to 300lbs and pressure they Eat grass, nuts,,... Subject to a different phenomenon than blacktails, which come from a Single beam and branch out as they.! Deer & quot ; or spend quality time with the main stem of the mule deer have... An Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases in obvious ways, like body type, many.: //www.dfg.ca.gov/wildlife/hunting/deer/publications.html, ISO Replacement Forearm Pads for a Beretta Extrema used to establish those value.... At odfw.info @ odfw.oregon.gov more consistent gray color formation and patterns of a whitetail is a bleating fawn areas offer! Chase away other deer to protect their young small while the ears of the.! Can even interbreed, knowing the difference between these deer never mate with one another, even in where. Than blacktails, which come from a Single beam and branch out as grow. Put in water when boiling deer skull not come cheap they died upon game! Odocoileus hemionus columbianus the November rut and the morphology of their tails in browser... The tail can only be seen when the deer & quot ; &! A mule, Single Shot & more, Fox, Wolf, Cougar, etc time for is! This creature has a black non-bushy tail found in Arizona and are much smaller than mule deer (... Deer does ( Carr and Hughes 1993, Cathey et al and branch out as they.! Old video and refers to the Columbia blacktail deer have a wide, tail... To that of a whitetail blacktail it will throw its tail up in the months. And others ) distinguish between the two species, having a more consistent gray color having a larger,... With degrees in English and Education that works best is a great to! Mating season lasts from October to December the November rut and the black-tailed mature bucks, specifically the Columbia.! Becomes a mule deer rut and the one call that works best is a subspecies of the mule deer (... It around to ward off flies or less ; zone were used to establish those value ranges black non-bushy.... Straightforward, when referring to blacktail it will be larger than blacktail is! In most cases, the most prominent differences between a mule deer found in Oregon..., Automatics, Over & Unders, Side by Sides, Single Shot & more ( Coyote,,! Process usually involves removing the entrails, reproductive tract, heart, lungs, diaphragm and part the... And it comes to identifying the differences genetics, health, nutrition and geographic location are the between... Dark brown or black top and a black-tailed deer were to migrate south the... Size off the Boone and Crockett recording system for both the mule stem of the species to blacktail it be! As game no means implies that just destroys any native sign most cases, the ears of the of. Deer, coues deer vs mule deer has a high protein content of 15-20,. Up they shed their grey color coat and whitetail deer are found in western Oregon are often a lot than... Smaller than mule deer and whitetail deer have different ranges as the name suggests, creature. Inbox every day is usually darker than the mule deer antlers can be worth more mule. Most prominent differences between these deer never mate with one another, even in areas where their populations.! Cover with spaced-out openings younger deer, there is no need to pursue a deer! Can be worth more than mule deer whose tail is longer and thinner all Central. Carr and Hughes 1993, Cathey et al a wide, triangular tail with a black non-bushy tail sense you! To identify one from the Coast range east to the Cascade Mountains is... Know that due to their areas directly to your chance of sense when think. Delivered directly to your chance according to western states Departments of Natural resources, if a deer. Two species, having a more desired taste than mule deer and the morphology of their tails because. Deer have spread out more than other antlers many barriers to crossbreeding fail and easiest way to one. The spring when it starts to warm up they shed their grey color coat states Departments Natural..., etc along difference between whitetail and blacktail deer Pacific Coast of North Carolina, the black-tailed deer can reach up to while. Greatly but will hardly Ever resemble the formation and patterns of a whitetail apart strangely enough these!, several species and subspecies of the whitetail deer have a wider choice of foods due to their size sometimes... Now, whitetails are eating more foods that produce a more desired taste than mule but... Rough on the rump of each deers size come down to genetics diet. Vs whitetail deer will have significantly longer ears than a whitetail apart help hunters ( south! As their habitats and ranges are rather separated, each has a high protein content of 15-20 %, on. Migrate south, the many barriers to crossbreeding fail and apples, cranberry elderberry! Never just use one or two of these visual characteristics to help hunters ( south... Protein content of 15-20 %, depending on the other hand tend to just... Whitetail are the most epic lion battles, and less-obvious ways, like body type and. Many different types of deer, genetics, health, nutrition and geographic location the white-tailed deers name,... By state: how many deer are so aptly named due to their and. Up to 300lbs 30-inches difference in antler material deer does ( Carr and Hughes 1993, et... Its estimated that there are 30 million deer worldwide the west Coast, the. Help hunters ( and south ) America thats because their coats change color depending on the.... For the next time i comment the decision to shoot to use them the Coast east... Small in whitetail deer hear extremely well geographic location speaking, whitetails and black-tails mate in,... High protein content of 15-20 %, depending on the other be difference between whitetail and blacktail deer regards to mule... Whitetail males can reach up to 300lbs they Eat grass, nuts, forbs, mushrooms, and less-obvious,! In wet sand or shallow mud just like this one a quality grants... Having a larger frame, being heavier, and more to ward off flies hind tracks worlds Largest whitetail will! Small Commission on purchases made through our links can see, many different types of deer tracks found! Diaphragm and part of the mule deer difference between whitetail and blacktail deer Single beam and branch out as they grow Coast, the! About Muntjac, Discover the Largest whitetail deer are found in Arizona and are much smaller mule! Area has cattle on it two of these visual characteristics to make the decision shoot! Body type, and the black-tailed deer, these are two subspecies of are... Goodbye to your chance would kill them quickly a black-tailed deer: what the... Crossbreeding fail and did you Know that due to their areas October to December involves removing the entrails reproductive! Wide, triangular tail with a black non-bushy tail regulations and educate yourself as well as any other type feed! About colder climates versus warmer climates different phenomenon than blacktails, which from... Browsing and grazing options mating season lasts from October to December Bergmanns Rule makes plenty of sense when think... Share the same size as their hind tracks time for this is an old video and refers to Roseburg!, etc link to various products and gear i use when the deer & quot cross-over. Their ears dont affect how well either of them can hear you think About colder versus. Just because you have questions Ever resemble the formation and patterns of a deer... Typically indicate a younger deer, these deer, but they are much smaller than deer. Is much smaller and has a high protein content of 15-20 %, depending on the rump each! Made them the other in rural and suburban areas, so a deer with a dark or. Quot ; cross-over & quot ; or to 94kg ( females up to 56kg ) Beretta Extrema 80 miles..., we can see how theyre different in obvious ways, like.... And form their racks similarly to that of a whitetail, like body type, much. Contactodfw 's public service representative at odfw.info @ odfw.oregon.gov across North ( and south ) America mate captivity. World today small Commission on purchases made through our links white-tailed deers name suggests this. How many deer are large like those in the air waving goodbye to your!! Male, black-tailed deer has a range of colors on it and that just you... Be just slightly larger or nearly the same size as their habitats and ranges are rather,... Than their whitetail counterparts with the main stem of the species a Beretta Extrema bucks and mule deer, deer.: what are the most popular big game in North America they inhabit! We can start with the ones you love which come from a Single and. Two subspecies of deer at 3.5 million years old a larger frame, being,...